When it comes to birthday parties, the centerpiece is often a beautifully decorated cake with a big pile of lit candles on top. This tradition is rooted in cultures all over the world and dates as far back as ancient Egypt and Greece, but the modern American version of this celebratory dessert can be traced to Germany. The Germans adapted the traditional Kinderfest cake to include a number of decorative layers, a rich frosting, and elaborate decorations that represent the celebrant’s age. Today, the birthday cake is still the most sought-after treat at any birthday celebration, and there are countless variations that fit the theme of the party or honor the celebrant’s favorite flavors.

When choosing the ideal birthday cake, it’s important to consider whether you’re looking for a classic vanilla option, a chocolate-y indulgence, or a carrot-y healthful variation. You may also want to pick a shape that matches the occasion or is an edible work of art (think roses, tiers of donuts, or stacks of cupcakes). For an extra special touch, a personalized message or design can be written in royal icing or frosting on top.

Whatever kind of cake you choose, there are a few things to keep in mind when baking it:

A cake’s texture and flavor are highly dependent on the type of flour used. Generally speaking, all-purpose flour produces the lightest and most fluffy cakes. If you prefer a dense, heavier cake, use whole wheat or spelt flour instead.

Likewise, the flavor of a cake can be influenced by the type of sugar in it. Confectioner’s sugar is a popular choice because it offers a smooth, sweet taste and gives many frostings their characteristic white color. However, many bakers also like to use granulated sugar because it’s a bit more affordable and just as flavorful.

Another key factor is the oven temperature. Make sure it’s properly preheated before you start baking, and don’t forget to grease and line the pan. This will make it much easier to remove the finished cake from the pan later on. Finally, don’t skimp on the mixing time – a stand or portable mixer is ideal for beating butter and sugar until they are creamy and light.

While there are many different types of cakes to choose from, the most popular is undoubtedly the Funfetti cake. While it’s hard to pinpoint the exact reason for this enduring popularity, Leah Morrow, executive pastry chef of Williamsburg Hotel and Brooklyn Bread Lab, thinks it has something to do with our nostalgia for childhood. “There is something magical about seeing sprinkles in a cake,” she says.

Whether you’re making a classic vanilla option, an easy carrot cake, or a showstopping atomic bomb, these cakes will make anyone feel special on their day. Plus, they’re perfect for sharing with friends and family at your next dinner party.